Mulberry Street, Bayswater, London

Massive New York style pizzas with delicious toppings. I have been going here for a few years now with friends. I don't think it's expensive and the quality is premium! The atmosphere is great and staff are very good.

December 2010
Quality of the pizzas have gone downhill

I have been a patron of mulberry street for some years. I no longer eat in as the service charge does not go to the waiting staff which i disagree with but we do order from time to time.

I am very dissapointed with the deteoriation in quality of the pizzas, they used to use good quality cheese and new york style toppings. The cheese is very poor quality now and it actually makes the pizza rather tasteless.

Im also not impressed that they no longer seem to use the new york style breaded eggplant which is difficult to get hold of in other restaurants and now doesnt exist on the pizza toppings here either. This isnt serious if you werent attached to it but the quality of the pizza is.

Im sure the profit margins have improved with the loss in quality but this regular customer can give them no more chances Im afraid. Please improve.

On the service side the delivery men (never had a woman) are always very nice. The staff in the restaurant sometimes have trouble understanding english over the phone but this doesnt deter me. Just the quality of the pizzas themselves!

I work in Notting Hill and I've eaten here dozens of times. I love the pizzas, especially the New York Hot. The 20" size are very big but one between two is pretty much spot on. I do sometimes order a whole one for myself (don't judge me - I get hungry!!) and if it's too much I usually take the rest home and it warms up very nicely in the oven. My other favourite is the meatball hero sandwich (sorry Subway but they got you nailed!) - add parmesan from the shakers - heaven!

Went here last week with the boyfriend, as I was really craving some home comforts. I really like how they set up the interior, but I disagree with someone who said that it looks like your typical US pizzeria. Its a bit more modern looking than the ones near me!

I was surprised that the pizza was fairly decent. I had an Eggplant Parm slice, and the bf had a Chicken Parm slice. We went for the lunch deal, so with a soda each, we paid only 10 quid in all. I'd definitely rather get a normal slice from here if I go again, because they do the toppings very oddly. I think we're all generally used to the topping being cooked INTO the pizza as its cooking, but no, these guys basically make plain cheese pizzas, and once they're finished, they put the topping on top.

I really didn't like that.

Also, there IS a better Italian style pizza place around. It's called Italian Pizza Connection, and its also on Westbourne Grove, but just east of Queensway. The pizza is a bit better, and you get more for your money. And the guys who work there are much friendlier than the people at Mulberry Street.

Sorry to write but this place was a very Bad Experience.

Went in there last night with the other half and had awful service, time and experience. Now I do not not want to sound negative but to have 5 basic things go wrong is Bad and awful.

1. They got the order for the Pizza wrong and advised we would have to wait another 20 mins for another Pizza. Fine. However we were there on a Sunday evening and no one was ordering and we seem to be the only table ordering as everyone else had eaten.

2. The drinks we ordered were taken and not delivered after 15 mins. I am not counting however they advised me to I had to wait for Cream Soda. Did not come. Why advertise?

3. Service was bad and a chef had to ask for waiter to come and serve us.

4. Piece of ice cube went flying pass as staff seemed happy to play fight with all customers watching. Come on guys do this when we have left.

5. Our bill was wrong and had to go back TWICE to fix it.

We spend nearly £35 for an awful experience and half the staff understood when I complained.

Not recommended.

I hate writing negative reviews...

This place is great! I read a terrible review of it in The Times and decided to go anyway and I’m so pleased I did. The pizzas are massive and get put on stands so they’re up out of the way (a nice touch!). We had two pizzas between five of us and we walked out with leftovers (that’s how big they are), we tried the white spinach pizza and an artichoke and parma ham. Both were excellent, made with lovely fresh ingredients. The interior is done up to look like a new york sports bar and most of the tables upstairs are booths. Ignore The Times and give it a go!

This is an American style pizzeria with tables both on the ground floor and in the basement. This is a US chain trying to look like your “local” pizzeria, or at least what a local pizzeria looks like in the US. The pizza is not bad and is served in one format, very large one to share (or by the slice) for around 3 people (£20). They have large TV screens with sports and cartoons so if you come with kids it’s a mixed blessing as they will be quiet during all the lunch/dinner and not really present at all as it is like eating in front of the TV.
They also have a new delivery service for W2, W11, W8 and W14, probably a good option if you need a big pizza to share with friends in front of a football game.
Oveall not a bad restaurant but nothing really special. Good option for families.

Mulberry Street is a great American style pizza place. The full pizzas you get are huge! And you would struggle to eat one between two, which is why it is so great that you can take away your left-overs (which by the way are lovely the next day!) and not in a gigantic box, they have subtle little food bags to out them in. A meal here is quite reasonable, especially as it is so filling, and the house wine is lovely. The also do takeaways and deliver to local areas (although I didn’t know that when I had to walk down the street with the biggest pizza box ever!)