Judy's Cafe (formerly Jimmy's Cafe), Northfield, Birmingham

fruity_tart Well, I can only go on MY personal experience - if yours was different write your own review! pmsl!

My review was written almost 12 months ago, things do change y'know? Or not that much really as my neighbour also commented about an appalling meal she had in Jimmys just last week. Do you have a vested interest in this business by any chance? Looking at your profile it seems you joined Qype simply to criticise my review, very odd.

I am not a 'large lady' and do not have a particularly big appetite but my portion was very small, I wouldn't have written that otherwise. And yes, I did think of my baby as she did in fact have chips off my scampi meal but as I said the meal was tiny and I also had to give my older daughter some.

I find the personal attacks in your comment a little hard to stomach, I also find the level of English a little bizarre and wonder if you are one of the Chinese ladies/gentlemen who work in Jimmys???

Oh well, next time you comment on one of my reviews please try to get your words in the correct order and cut the personal attacks. I look forward to reading your Jimmy's review, if you can string the words together to write one that is!

lisa064 I find it hard to believe that you could infact comment about my intellectual intelligence in the english language, it may be because i didnt take my time to write you a formal message across the internet however i must inform you that i actually have an A level in english language and literature, making me in fact more qualified in the english language then you are.

Another problem with your message which i would like to address is the fact that you could comment that i have a 'invested interest' in the business, i have in fact got no connections at all to the business as it is clear from visiting the cafe that it is a family run business, and as i am NOT part of the family, i find it very unlikely evidently that i have an 'invested interest in the business.' The third problem i would like to address would be you saying that because my english in writing you a comment on how unfair and unjust your comments were, i could be in fact one of the 'chinese workers' in the cafe. I am in fact NOT one of the workers, and have never worked in the catering business in my whole life. I DID however set up the account to write a review on Jimmy's and comment on the unfair review that I have read. I was looking to see whether or not there was a website on the cafe, and what i came across was your review. In the moment of discontent for such a harsh review i felt it was only right to write one back to tell the readers what i felt, while submitting my review i saw that i had in fact had to sign up to write a review, so that is what i did.

If you do point accusations on me being part of the business, then i would like to inform you that this is not the case at all. I would also like to say that even though by reading my one review and one comment, it may look as though i may be part of Jimmys Cafe establishment, i am in fact not into all this 'public reviewing' and find it funny how you write reviews for 'argos and greggs' maybe it would be nicer for you to stop reviewing things for fun and find a real hobby.

My wishes today are to keep this matter closed. And for the most part not get involved in a personal battle with you as this would not be what i wish for. Nor do i defend jimmys in a personal way, but instead i defend it in a just manner, one of which i stand for as i dont like seeing harsh comments pointed in the way of a cafe of which i am fond of going to presently.

if you do not understand any of this.. then maybe you yourself, should learn some English upto a A Level standard, and get yourself a degree in History in Birmingham Univeristy. Instead of wasting your life away reviewing everything around you and not feeling as though you yourself should be reviewed. Most probably you should review yourself before you review others.

Lisa Nettleford.